Vital Football

Latest Reading FC News

Scout report: Forest fan on McCleary

Scout report: Forest fan on McCleary
With great thanks (again) to Nottingham Forest season ticket holder Howard (@Howcro), we have asked a few questions on our new signing Garath McCleary. We uncover his strengths and weaknesses and whether he can crack it in the Premier League, despite only just doing it at Championship level.


1) If I would have told you two years ago that McCleary would be playing Premier League football in two years, what would have your reaction been?

I would've laughed, assuming it was other than getting there with Forest. McCleary was a fringe player until the start of this year. He'd often shown some potential, usually as an impact sub, but for whatever reason he never got a regular run in the team until Cotterill came in. Certainly two years I ago I'd have been surprised if most Premier League clubs had even heard of him.

2) What are his strengths?

He's got pace and is a lively winger. He found his goalscoring touch in the second half of last season and galvanised the team with his form. He likes to run at defenders and get crosses in. 9 goals and 7 assists is a decent return, especially as he didn't start playing regularly until December.

3) What are his weaknesses?

He's been injured a fair bit. He sometimes suffers from the 'run now, think later' sort of approach, in that he gets into a good position then doesn't know what to do with it. Also the first three Forest managers he played under either couldn't get the best out of him or decided he wasn't good enough, make of that what you will.

4) Do you think his form was a huge factor in you pushing away from the relegation zone in March and April?

Yes there's no doubt he played a big part in our survival, obviously the four goals against Leeds being the highlight. I think he benefitted from having an extended run in the team and knowing he'd be starting every game, as he picked up form his confidence grew and he was one of the key players we looked to for goals.

5) What are our personal feelings about him leaving on a bosman?

I think we will miss him, but if you'd asked me at the start of the year I'd have said we wouldn't - he's far from irreplaceable. I can't blame him for going, he caught the eye with his performances and has tripled his wages from what I've read. Given the uncertainty over ownership and future of the club, it's not surprising he turned down a new contract at the time.

6) Do you think he could do a job in the Premier League?

I have my doubts - he's only really had one good half season with us, apart from that he hasn't had much impact in four years. He may have just been putting himself in the shop window knowing he was out of contract. However, perhaps he just needed a manager to show faith in him.

Join The Vital Debate

Date:Tuesday July 31 2012
Time: 1:58PM


He only got a handful of starts under Billy Davis's in his two year reign at the club who preffered the more workman like anderson, aswell as dealing with a knee injury which had plagued him for a long time which may give one an idea as to why he hasn't had as much impact as one would of liked in his time with us. He only played under three mangers, he was mainly used as an impact substitute under Colin Calderwood and Billy Davis until Steve Cottrells arrival. He was injured througout Steve Mclarens tenure. To say he was just putting himself in the shop window would suggest he never tried before his prolific final few months at forest which I find very hard to believe considering the lads attitude and where he has had to work his way up from. I don't think he had planned on Steve Cottrell coming in and giving him a decent run in the side which obviously improved him as a player and gave him confidence not to mention getting over his injury. I would also say his 'run now think later' as suggested above has now been erased because of this as game time is key to a players development and decision making. I can honestly say without his contribution we would now be preparing for life in League One. He's not irreplaceable but free scoring quick two footed tricky wingers at this level are not cheap. As long as he is injury free I think he will give a good account of himself in the prem.
31/07/2012 18:04:00
Thats a great insight tarder, much appreciated!
31/07/2012 22:20:00
oh Joshy you love your job!
02/08/2012 12:14:00
Page 1/1
  1. 1

Login to post a comment

Recent Reading Articles

Stats: Arsenal v Reading

All the stats from Arsenal (2) vs (0) Reading, Emirates Stadium, 25/10/16 Att: 59,865

Team Sheets - Arsenal v Reading

Reading go to the Emirates Stadium as the visitors to Arsenal for the latest EFL Cup match.

Team news & possible line ups - Arsenal vs Reading

We take a look at some team news and possible starting XIs ahead of our cup encounter with Arsenal tonight.

Vital View - League Cup, 25th-26th October

The 2016-17 League Cup continues with the latest round of matches this midweek, which will see us among those having a match with a fifth round place the aim of course.

Archived Vital Reading Articles

Vital Reading articles from

Site Journalists

Write for Vital Reading
Write For Vital Reading
Apply Here

Current Poll (see more polls)

ELC - Arsenal MotM
Suggested By: Site Staff
Al Habsi0%
van den Berg0%
Sub - Kermorgant0%
Sub - Gravenberch0%
Sub - Quinn0%
ScoopDragon Publishing Entire League Network of Sites

League Table

# Team P W D L Pts. GD
1 Newcastle 14 10 1 3 31 19
2 Brighton 14 8 4 2 28 9
3 Huddersfield 14 9 1 4 28 4
4 Norwich 14 8 3 3 27 7
5 Sheff Wed 14 7 3 4 24 1
6 Bristol City 14 7 2 5 23 6
7 Birmingham 14 6 5 3 23 3
8 Reading 14 6 4 4 22 -3
9 Preston 14 6 2 6 20 1
10 Leeds Utd 14 6 2 6 20 -1
11 Brentford 14 5 4 5 19 5
12 Barnsley 14 6 1 7 19 3
13 Q.P.R. 14 5 4 5 19 -3
14 Fulham 14 4 6 4 18 -2
15 Burton 14 4 5 5 17 0
16 Aston Villa 14 3 8 3 17 0
17 Ipswich 14 4 5 5 17 -2
18 Wolves 14 4 4 6 16 -1
19 Forest 14 4 3 7 15 -3
20 Cardiff 14 4 3 7 15 -9
21 Derby County 14 3 5 6 14 -4
22 Blackburn 14 3 3 8 12 -8
23 Wigan 14 2 5 7 11 -3
24 Rotherham 14 1 3 10 6 -19
The Vital Football Members League
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
Vital Football Comment

Recent Reading Results (view all)

Reading Fixtures (view all)

Oct 29 2016 3:00PM : Nottingham Forest (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 5 2016 3:00PM : Wigan Athletic (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 19 2016 3:00PM : Burton Albion (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Nov 26 2016 3:00PM : Bristol City (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 3 2016 3:00PM : Fulham (a)
Sky Bet Championship
Dec 10 2016 3:00PM : Sheffield Wednesday (H)
Sky Bet Championship
Write for Vital Football